Colorado is conflicted about cutting its water use

By Dave Marston

In Colorado, farmers must enroll in a four-state program by March 1, if they want to get paid for fallowing their fields perhaps the best option to plump up the Colorado River’s giant reservoirs, Mead and Powell.

Not everyone is a fan, including Andy Mueller, director of the Colorado River District. He doesn’t like programs that pay farmers to stop farming. Mueller also didn’t ask for the Inflation Reduction Act’s $125 million to pay the farmers he represents. Mueller’s organization exists to keep Western Colorado’s rural water away from growing cities across the Rockies.

State Sen. Dylan Roberts, D-Avon, who chairs the Committee for Agriculture and Natural Resources, has a more nuanced view. He says he understands that rural communities fear a “buy and dry” scenario. Where annual leases become routine, and once-verdant fields and farms wither. He insists that any water leasing must be temporary, voluntary and well compensated.

A water-leasing program called demand management was created for Colorado irrigators under former Colorado Gov. John Hickenlooper — it was tested, but never used. It would have allowed farmers to lease and store their water in a Lake Powell account under state control. Under Gov. Jared Polis’ administration, however, demand management was quietly shelved.

Now, this new, multi-state program for leasing agricultural water, called a “system conservation pilot program,” isn’t getting much traction. The program was announced two and a half months ago by Utah, Colorado, New Mexico, and Wyoming.

Its major drawback, says Tom Kay, an organic farmer in western Colorado, is that the Upper Colorado River Commission is offering a “stupid price of $150 an acre-foot.”

“Farmers like to farm; you have to pay them more than they make farming to interest them,” Kay adds. He gets around $650 per acre-foot of water growing mostly organic corn and dry beans on his 350-acre farm near the town of Hotchkiss.

Kay says he recently toured California’s Imperial Valley, where farmers are getting $679 an acre-foot. They sell their 200,000 acre-feet of Colorado River to the San Diego County Water Authority and consider the price reasonable.

Water prices are also rising. In California last summer, when the Bureau of Reclamation was looking hard for water, large irrigation districts in the Lower Basin were asking $1,500 per acre-foot to lease their water to cities, reported Janet Wilson of California’s Desert Sun.

If farmers got more money for their water under the new pilot program, says State Sen. Roberts, Colorado “could get more participation (and) show the federal government we are doing our part.” He also says that many state legislators think California and Arizona should bear the brunt of water cuts.

Getting farmers to fallow their land could build resilience in the Colorado River Basin, says Aaron Derwingson of The Nature Conservancy. A few years ago, he worked with grower Kay and Cary Denison, formerly of Trout Unlimited, to develop an “organic transition” program whose concept was simple: Lease two-thirds of your water for three years so pesticides and fertilizers leach off the land, then apply for organic certification. The demand management trial was largely funded by the Bureau of Reclamation.

So the question remains: Why is the Upper Colorado River Commission offering farmers so little for their irrigation water? The commission’s executive director, Chuck Cullom, explains: “$150 per acre-foot was chosen to discourage drought profiteering.”

Kay guesses that the low price was set to discourage participation. While $150 is the floor, and farmers can negotiate for more, commission representatives haven’t gone to agricultural communities to beat the drum for its program.

Kay says, “That $125 million is a lot of money, and it belongs to Upper Basin farmers.”

Meanwhile, in mid-November, 30 western cities agreed to cut “non-functional” turf grass by up to 36%, including big water guzzlers such as Utah’s Washington County, which wants to siphon more water out of Lake Powell.

What’s unclear is how much water from not watering grass stays in the river. Mueller points out that Aurora, a fast-growing Denver suburb, “is cutting water to sell more water taps. They’re building more houses.”

Kay admires Mueller’s rural leadership but thinks the way forward is clear: “Denver has a junior water right. Why isn’t it paying us in western Colorado to fallow ground, just like what Los Angeles and San Diego are doing?”

Dave Marston is the publisher of Writers on the Range, an independent nonprofit dedicated to spurring lively conversation about the West. He owns a small, irrigated parcel in Western Colorado.

Tom Kay in front of his John Deere tractor, image: Dave Marston

This column was published in the following newspapers:

02/27/2023 Four Points Press Garryowen MT
02/27/2023 Vail Daily Vail CO
02/27/2023 Montrose Daily Press Montrose CO
02/27/2023 Steamboat Pilot Steamboat Springs CO
02/27/2023 Craig Daily Press Craig co
02/27/2023 Lake Powell Chronicle Page AZ
02/27/2023 Fort Morgan Times Fort Morgan CO
02/28/2023 Salt Lake Tribune Salt Lake City UT
02/28/2023 Boulder Daily Camera Boulder CO
02/28/2023 Marinscope community newspapers Marin County CA
02/28/2023 Sterling Journal-Advocate Sterling CO
02/28/2023 Denver Post Denver CO
02/28/2023 Kingman Daily Miner Kingman AZ
03/01/2023 Grand Junction Daily Sentinel Grand Junction CO
03/01/2023 Carlsbad Current-Argus Carsbad NM
03/01/2023 Yahoo sunnyvale ca
03/01/2023 Greeley Tribune Greeley CO
03/02/2023 Wyoming Tribune Eagle Cheyenne WY
03/02/2023 Moab Times Independent Moab UT
03/02/2023 Wenatchee World Wenatchee WA
03/02/2023 Taos News Taos NM
03/02/2023 Glenwood Post Independent Glenwood Springs CO
03/02/2023 Pagosa Springs Sun Pagosa Springs CO
03/04/2023 Sky-Hi News Granby CO
03/05/2023 Coyote Gulch Denver CO
03/06/2023 Cortez Journal Cortez CO
03/06/2023 Durango Herald Durango CO
03/07/2023 Summit Daily frisco co
03/09/2023 Del Norte Triplicate Crescent City CA
03/09/2023 Boulder Weekly Boulder CO
03/09/2023 Canyon Courier Courier Co
03/06/2023 Explore Big Sky Big Sky MT
03/08/2023 Park Record Park City UT
03/11/2023 Aspen Times Aspen CO
03/10/2023 Curry Coastal Pilot Brookings OR
03/07/2023 Arvada Press Arvada Co
03/07/2023 The Golden Transcript Golden Co
03/02/2023 Twin Falls Times News Twin Falls ID
03/22/2023 Leadville Herald-Democrat Leadville CO
03/07/2023 Jeffco Transcript Jefferson County CO
0 0 votes
Article Rating
Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
#Colorado is conflicted about cutting its #water use — Writers on the Range – Coyote Gulch
1 year ago

[…] the link to read the article on the Writers on the Range website (David […]

Southwestern Water Conservation District’s 2023 annual seminar recap — The #Durango Herald – Coyote Gulch
1 year ago

[…] saved (an acre-foot is the amount needed to submerge an acre of land in 1 foot of water), while farmers can typically harness far more in profits from that water if they use it for […]

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Once a week you’ll receive an email with a link to our weekly column along with profiles of our writers, beside quirky photos submitted from folks like you. Don’t worry we won’t sell our list or bombard you with daily mail.

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x