Is the American Dream fading in the West?

By Benjamin Waddell

I recently spent two days with a Mexican national named Alfredo because his experience and many of his surprising opinions seemed widely shared: America, he’s concluded, isn’t worth the struggle.

“The last time I crossed into the U.S., we had to walk for seven days under constant rain,” Alfredo told me. “I’m glad I never have to do that again.”

We were hiking a trail near his home in central Mexico, where rain had turned the land green, with maturing cornfields flanked by rows of beans and squash. 

For years, Alfredo, 37, worked as a landscaper and also as a roofer in the American Southwest. These days, though, he stays home. “My land is full of life. I only left my country like everyone else because I had to. I was poor and back then it was a violent place.”

Alfredo lives in the state of Guanajuato, which is among the top migrant-sending states in Mexico. Now, roughly 10.9 million Mexican-born residents live in America, and the majority came from small towns like the one I was walking through.

I thought of my parents, who left Iowa and Arkansas in the 1970s to head West. In their case they were fleeing segregation, but like Alfredo, they were in search of opportunity. In 1974, they moved to Telluride, Colorado, then a busted mining town aspiring to become another Aspen. That first winter they lived in the back of a van while they remodeled an old mining shack, which they purchased for $20,000. Neither had a college education, but in those days a degree wasn’t required to aspire to a middle-class life.

My father worked construction and my mom waited tables. Money was tight, but the first ski lift had just gone in, and the future looked promising. These days, both continue to work, but they are financially stable in large part because of the equity in a house they owned decades ago.

Today, opportunities in the West are harder to come by. My childhood home in Telluride, although no longer in the family, recently appraised for just over $5 million, representing a 24,900% increase since my parents first purchased it. Wages, in turn, have been stuck in neutral for decades. And while wandering hippies may still show up in vans, few are able to purchase property of their own unless they’re packing a trust fund. As the middle-class fades away, what’s left seems to narrow down to property owners and workers.

If he’d been born a few decades earlier, Alfredo said, he might have tried to stay in the United States. “But all I did in the U.S. was work from sunup to sundown, and for what? At least here I have my home and my cornfields, I get to see my family every day, and I’m connected to the land.”

Alfredo’s not alone. Today, more migrants are returning to Mexico than are leaving. The outflow back to Mexico is affecting Western states particularly hard, because most of the Mexicans who do migrate to this country are settling in southern states like Arkansas, North Carolina and Georgia. Similar trends are evident within smaller sending countries like El Salvador, Haiti, Honduras and Guatemala.

According to my research, the migrants returning to Mexico tend to leave states such as Arizona, California, Colorado and Texas. These demographic shifts have contributed to an acute labor shortage.

For generations, Mexican migrants subsidized the expansion of the West by providing cheap workers. Men like Alfredo worked alongside newcomers like my parents, and together, they helped build now-legendary towns like Telluride. Now, just as Mexican migration rates reverse, the cost of construction, housing, and basic services in the West are all on the rise.

As we settled into the trail toward Alfredo’s hometown of San Martin de Terreros, I asked Alfredo if he planned to come back to the U.S. one day. “No, señor,” he responded without hesitation. “I have everything I need right here.”

Benjamin Waddell is a contributor to Writers on the Range, writersontherange.org, an independent nonprofit dedicated to spurring lively conversation about the West. He is an associate professor of sociology at Fort Lewis College in Durango, Colorado.

This column was published in the following newspapers:

12/07/2021 Beaverton Valley Times Beaverton OR
12/07/2021 Twin Falls Times News Twin Falls ID
12/07/2021 Grand Junction Daily Sentinel Grand Junction CO
12/06/2021 Anchorage Daily Press Anchorage AK
12/06/2021 Vail Daily Vail CO
12/07/2021 Sublette Examiner Pinedale WY
12/07/2021 Tigard Times Tigard OR
12/07/2021 Forest Grove News Times Forest Grove OR
12/07/2021 Hillsboro Times News Hillsboros OR
12/07/2021 Columbia County Spotlight Scappose OR
12/07/2021 Salt Lake Tribune Salt Lake City UT
12/07/2021 Steamboat Pilot Steamboat Springs CO
12/08/2021 Jackson Hole News & Guide Jackson Hole WY
12/08/2021 Montrose Daily Press Montrose CO
12/08/2021 Idaho Mountain Express Ketchum ID
12/08/2021 Delta County Independent Delta CO
12/10/2021 Aspen Daily News Aspen CO
12/08/2021 Carlsbad Current-Argus Carsbad NM
12/09/2021 Explore Big Sky Big Sky MT
12/10/2021 Moab Times Independent Moab UT
12/09/2021 Ruidoso Daily News Ruidoso New Mexico
12/09/2021 Alamogordo Daily News Alamogordo NM
12/11/2021 Las Vegas Sun Las Vegas NV
12/09/2021 Yahoo Finance sunnyvale ca
12/11/2021 Casper Star Tribune Casper WY
12/13/2021 Bandon Western World Bandon OR
12/13/2021 Del Norte Triplicate Crescent City CA
12/13/2021 Colorado Springs North Springs edition Colorado Springs co
12/13/2021 Big Timber Pioneer Big Timber MT
12/15/2021 Aspen Times Aspen CO
12/17/2021 Craig Daily Press Craig co
12/15/2021 Curry Coastal Pilot Brookings OR
12/19/2021 Fort Morgan Times Fort Morgan CO
12/19/2021 Sterling Journal-Advocate Sterling CO
12/13/2021 Pikes Peak Courier Woodland CO

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Once a week you’ll receive an email with a link to our weekly column along with profiles of our writers, beside quirky photos submitted from folks like you. Don’t worry we won’t sell our list or bombard you with daily mail.